Skip to Main Content

Bethel University Library: A Brief Guide for Faculty

Making the Implicit Explicit: Seeing Assignments from a Student Perspective

Differences between faculty and student understandings and approaches to library research and related assignments often create frustration both for the students and ultimately the faculty who must evaluate the product. 

Below are a few examples of those differences:

General Characteristics and Assumptions

Faculty Students
  • Expert learners and researchers
  • Novices learning how to learn and do research
  • Specialized field of interest/research
  • Taking courses in a broad range of subject areas
  • Learning the tools in their major field
  • Large vocabulary especially in their field and know synonyms and related concepts   
  • Learning terminology and often don't know which concepts are related
  • Generally use one computer platform and specific desktop or laptop
  • May need to use a variety of computers with different software, setup, etc.  This may especially true for CAPS/GS students.
  • Assume students learned a great deal of research skills in ILA, College Writing, Academic Research Writing, or in another class in their program   
  • College Writing classes vary a great deal
  • Library Instruction for a class or cohort may have been months ago
  • Students don't tend to remember from just one experience

Students outside with laptop

Assignments and Student Responses
 

Examples of Assignments Given
 
Responses Librarians Hear From Students
 
  • Include three scholarly journals in your bibliography
  • What makes a journal scholarly?
  • What's the difference between scholarly, trade, and popular periodicals?
  • Actually, what is a journal or periodical?
     
  • You may have only 25% of your sources from the web
  • I found all these articles in "Academic Search Premier" so I have enough information for my paper, but I have to have something that isn't on the web
     
  • Research the "learning styles of teenagers"
  • There was only one article in "Academic Search Premier"!
  • Possible questions from librarians:
    • Did you try (teen* or adolescen* or high school student*) when placing your search?
    • Did you try "cognitive style*" as well as "learning style*" in your search?
    • Did you try searching in the "ERIC" or "PsycINFO" databases as well?

       
  • Print all of the graphs in your handout in color
  • Color?!  Every color copy costs me nine pages!
     
  • Create your bibliography in an appropriate format
  • What does "appropriate format" mean?
  • How should I format my references?